Tag Archive for: West Africa

Australian still being held in Mali despite prisoner swap

In a major hostage exchange in Mali earlier this month, nearly 200 jihadists held by the Mali government were swapped for a French woman, two Italians and a kidnapped Malian politician. The exchange didn’t include Australian surgeon Ken Elliott, 85, who has been held by jihadists there since January 2016.

Those released were French aid worker Sophie Petronin and Italians Father Pierluigi Maccalli and tourist Nicola Chiacchio, along with prominent Malian politician Soumaila Cisse.

Why Elliott wasn’t included is not clear. The Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade says it engages in ‘quiet diplomacy’ in hostage cases involving Australians but does not seem to have been involved in this latest round of talks, either through our high commission in Ghana (the post responsible for Mali) or the Australian embassy in Paris.

It’s possible that Australia was not even aware of the exchange negotiations.

France is the former colonial ruler and still has the most influence of any external power in the region. It has 5,100 soldiers deployed across the Sahel region as part of its anti-jihadist Operation Barkhane. The force is headquartered at N’Djamena, the capital of Chad, with French forces located in Burkina Faso, Chad, Mali, Mauritania and Niger. The US has about 1,200 military personnel in West Africa, with a significant percentage in Niger, which has become the key American hub on that side of the continent.

Elliott and his wife, Joyce, first moved to Djibo in Burkina Faso, which borders Mali, in 1972. There they built a hospital and performed medical procedures on people from across the region. Because of their advanced age, they had been trying unsuccessfully to get someone else to take over the unsalaried running of the hospital.

On 16 January 2016, the Elliotts were abducted from the hospital by an Islamist extremist group from across the border in Mali. Jocelyn was released weeks later after the group said it did not involve women in war, but she was more likely released because of her age and the adverse local reaction to her detention.

Back then, the group holding Elliott called itself ‘Emirate of the Sahara’. This group was linked to Al-Qaeda in the Islamic Maghreb (AQIM) and led by Algerian Abu Yahya al Hammam.

On 2 March 2017, the Sahara branch of AQIM merged with the Macina Liberation Front, Ansar Dine, Al-Mourabitoun and other smaller groups to become Jama’at Nasr al-Islam wal Muslimin (JNIM) (meaning ‘Group to Support Islam and Muslims’), led by Tuareg militant Iyad Ag Ghali. JNIM became the official branch of Al-Qaeda in Mali after the various group leaders swore allegiance to al-Qaeda leader Ayman al-Zawahiri.

The group holding Elliott would now be part of JNIM.

JNIM is mainly located in northern Mali, but an early 2020 report by Burkina Faso’s L’Evenement newspaper said Elliott was being guarded by 20 armed men in Mali’s central Mopti region. That may no longer be the case as hostages are moved frequently due to JNIM’s concerns about recovery raids by French and US special forces.

Other JNIM hostages are Colombian nun Gloria Cecilia Narváez Argoti, South African Christo Bothma and Romanian Julian Ghergut.

Released hostage Sophie Petronin told French authorities that JNIM had killed Swiss hostage Beatrice Stoeckli ‘about a month ago’.

AQIM has a long history of taking hostages in the Sahara and Sahel; it is estimated to have raised at least US$50 million through kidnap for ransom.

All of the Islamist groups in Mali aspire to displace the country’s French-backed government and replace it with a caliphate run by clerics under sharia law. The eight-year-old jihadist insurgency that began in the north of Mali has spread to the country’s centre and is now affecting bordering Niger and Burkina Faso.

Trying to organise a hostage release in Mali is undoubtedly complicated due to the number of Islamist factions involved, poor communications, large area and poor infrastructure. This year Covid-19 has been an additional factor.

Mali is also in the aftermath of a military coup that toppled President Ibrahim Boubacar Keita on 18 August. Keita was replaced on 25 September by an interim president, Bah Ndaw, a former foreign minister and retired colonel selected by the military junta. Ndaw has appointed a 25-member government, in which four key posts have gone to colonels.

However, despite the many difficulties involved, this latest exchange was probably the best opportunity to get Elliott released in the nearly five years since he was taken hostage. JNIM’s apparent reluctance to release him is probably due to his value to the group as a medical doctor, which hopefully means he is being reasonably well treated.

Australia should now be involved in the debriefing of the released European hostages to gain more information about Elliott’s situation.

Tackling global extremism: the case of Boko Haram

 

Since it was formed by Mohammed Yusuf in the early 2000s, Boko Haram, or Jama’a Ahl as-Sunna Li-da’wa wa-al Jihad (roughly translated from Arabic as ‘people committed to the propagation of the Prophet’s teachings and jihad), has become one of the most violent Islamist groups in the world. It has been responsible for the deaths of approximately 20,000 people and the displacement of over a million.

Boko Haram’s goal is to establish an Islamic state in northern Nigeria. In doing so, it has committed numerous atrocities, ranging from kidnapping and enslaving girls to carrying out scorched-earth policies and sporadic killings in local communities.

Boko Haram is now losing territory in northern Nigeria, leading it to seek safe haven in neighbouring states. That has led to an upsurge of violence in the wider Lake Chad region.

It appears that endogenous and exogenous factors have caused the group to splinter into three broad factions. One branch is led by Abubakar Shekau, who took over the group after the death of Mohammed Yusuf in 2009. The other key faction is now known as ‘Islamic State West Africa Province’, which pledges allegiance to Islamic State and also operates in Niger, Chad and Cameroon. Since August 2016 it has been led by Abu Musab al-Barnawi, Mohammed Yusuf’s second son. A third faction, about which little is known, is led by the Cameroon-born Mamman Nur, who is suspected to have connections to al-Shabab and al-Qaeda of the Islamic Maghreb.

On a trip to Nigeria late last month, UK Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson and International Development Secretary Priti Patel announced a £200 million development aid package over the next five years, including funds for deradicalising Boko Haram fighters. Very little information was provided about how the aid would be used beyond referring to it as humanitarian aid, which mean that natural concerns emerge that it may end up in the hands of the Nigerian military. In 2015, Nigeria’s President Muhammadu Buhari replaced Fatima Akilu, a UK-trained psychologist who had set up a rehabilitation program for Boko Haram fighters (partly funded by Britain and the EU) with an army colonel, raising concerns about the direction of the program.

Reaching out to key countries such as Nigeria that are battling extremist and radicalised groups has become a crucial mission for the international community. In 2006, the UN established the Counter-Terrorism Implementation Task Force (CTITF) to aid in the coordination of counterterrorism efforts.

Deradicalisation is an important tool in defeating terrorism. Increasingly, it seems to focus on dealing with those who have embraced Islamic terrorism and who the state now wishes to reform. That helps explain why the EU has also provided over €60 million for deradicalisation of Boko Haram fighters. The United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), with the support of the Japanese government, has sought to interact with women, with a focus on civil society organisations. In Nigeria, the UNDP has partnered with the Centre for Democracy and Development to establish a community dialogue, mainly through women’s groups, and including the Nigerian army, to discuss deradicalisation in the northeast of the country. The rationale is that by educating women one educates the family. The CTITF’s engagement in Nigeria has centred on building community resilience against terrorism, improving cooperation among law enforcement agencies, and strengthening judicial institutions.

Two broad approaches to deradicalisation are apparent within Nigeria. Many of the Boko Haram recruits aren’t willing participants, but rather kidnapped and radicalised individuals. The Nigerian government, through its Office of the National Security Advisor and Countering Violent-Extremism program, claims that it provides women who have been kidnapped by Boko Haram and male defectors with psychological care that includes addressing PTSD. There are also efforts to counter-radicalise and to prevent individuals and communities that may be susceptible to Boko Haram’s message from joining the group. Local development programs are vital in that context. As Max Schott, the chief UN humanitarian coordinator for Cameroon, declared, ‘It is essential to address the root causes of the crisis by addressing poverty, marginalization and underdevelopment’.

Northern Nigeria, the area where Boko Haram operates, is underdeveloped and remains dangerous. The military continues to carry out counterterrorism operations, which makes it difficult to access the area and undertake monitoring. The fact that the Nigerian military has been accused of gross human rights violations feeds into Boko Haram’s narrative that it is fighting an entity—the Nigerian state—that oppresses people living in the northern regions of Borno and Yobe.

Nigeria is clearly seeking to address the threat posed by Boko Haram. It’s comforting to know that the international community and individual states such as Britain recognise a need to support domestic efforts to counter radicalisation and violent extremism. However, it doesn’t appear that the Nigerian government is addressing many of the root causes of terrorism, which relate to poverty, underdevelopment and environmental damage. The Nigerian National Bureau of Statistics noted in 2012 that 61% of all Nigerians—nearly 100 million people—earned less than $1 a day in 2010; a petty trader in Kano earns less than $3 a day. Education is non-existent unless it is madrassa-based, leading to a common claim that policymakers only care about lining their own pockets. That feeds into the radical agenda propounded by extremist groups, led by Boko Haram.

Assessing the Ebola outbreak

Scanning electron micrograph of Ebola virus budding from the surface of a Vero cell (African green monkey kidney epithelial cell line. Credit: NIAID

The diagnosis of the first case of ‘imported’ Ebola in the US has heightened public awareness and anxiety over the current outbreak in west Africa. The development sits atop a wave of recent depressing assessments. Last week, the Center for Disease Control issued a projection that tried to allow for the infection rate beyond the official count, and that factored in the rate at which infections are doubling in the different west African countries. That report makes for sobering reading: it’s the source of the latest projection of a possible 1.4 million cases by January 2015. Moreover, CDC has revised upward its estimate of the virus’s morbidity rate, from roughly 50% to a more precise 71%. That’s a high figure.

The World Health Organisation has added to those concerns by noting that we might be witnessing a long-term shift of the virus out of the animal kingdom to become endemic in the human population. And the International Crisis Group has pointed to the social and political dynamics associated with the outbreak, suggesting we might see the ‘collapse’ of west African nations under the burden that Ebola is imposing. Read more