Tag Archive for: General

Sea, air and land updates

An F-22 Raptor

Sea State

Last Thursday, the US Navy’s Naval Intelligence Office released an unclassified report on the Chinese Navy (PLAN), the first in six years. The report provides the public with a wider analysis of issues such as China’s topical maritime claims in the South China Sea (SCS). The report’s major revelations include a projection that, by the end of 2015, the Chinese Coast Guard (CCG) will be 25% larger than it was three years ago, and that the CCG has more ships than Japan, Vietnam, Indonesia, Malaysia and the Philippines combined. It also reports PLAN’s deployment of the YJ-18—a new-generation supersonic anti-ship cruise missile—with the potential to seriously threaten the defences of US and allied ships.

Still on PLAN-related news, China has recently launched a second modified Type 904A supply ship. It’s more than just a flight deck: the vessel has a hangar too, which improves its aviation support facilities. Chinese media has reported that the ship will contribute to troop transport and logistics supply to barracks in the SCS.

And finally, The Diplomat has published an interesting article on an unconventional approach to resolving disputes in the SCS. According to Admiral Dennis Blair, the former director of national intelligence and commander-in-chief of the US Pacific Command, an ‘International Conference on the South China Sea’ would help ‘establish clarity on how to resolve conflicting claims’ by utilizing a two-step process. First, a conference would be held involving the SCS claimants with the objective of creating a rough international solution, and second, the claimant nations would then adopt the results of the conference as if they were the ‘new ground reality’ in the SCS. The plan would also be legitimised and enforced by the international community.

Flight Path

According to a new study, the future of air warfare looks set to include more bombers.  The US Center for Budgetary and Strategic Assessments says that America’s future war planes will look more like stealthy long-range bombers than sleek, fast and manoeuvrable fighters. The study suggests that the traditional fighter attributes of speed and manoeuvrability are less important to success today and into the future. The conclusion raises questions about the utility of a sixth generation fighter that will be a marginally-improved F-22 with limited short-range capability.

And it seems that the bombers of the future will have upgradability (also known as ‘modularity’ or ‘spiral development’) written into their design specifications. Recent revelations by senior Pentagon officials suggest the long-range strike bomber will be made to accommodate incremental improvement over the years, providing flexibility to counter future threats for the first time.

Last week Canada joined the airstrike campaign in Syria. Canadian Prime Minster Stephen Harper received approval from the parliament to launch airstrikes in Syria, noting that Canada would inform the Syrian government of its operations over the country, but not seek formal permission. Defence One has provided an excellent breakdown of the 5,548 Coalition airstrikes in Syria against ISIS since 2014, available here in easy-to-read graphs. (See also ASPI’s Strategy paper on the first 100 days of airstrikes against ISIS,)

Japan’s shift from ‘passive ‘to ‘proactive’ defence strategy is playing out in space. In January this year Japan finalised plans to launch its 10-year national security space build-up strategy mandated in its 2013 National Security Strategy. In case you missed it, the Basic Plan integrates space policy into national security strategy and seeks to enhance the US-Japan alliance. The program is designed to enhance Japan’s situational awareness and reconnaissance in space, and its space-based missile early warning capabilities.

Rapid Fire

Pakistan’s parliament has rejected a request to send air, naval and ground support to assist Saudi Arabia in its campaign against Houthi rebels in Yemen. The request comes as Saudi Arabia remains hesitant to send in any ground support of their own.  Over at Al Jazeera, Gamal Gasim argues why a Coalition military ground incursion would be a poor strategic choice given other relative strengths, such as political and diplomatic avenues. Pakistan justified the move as an attempt to remain impartial so that it might play a diplomatic role in the future, a decision that’s caused a rift with its allies in the Gulf. The US has taken a different approach, announcing an increase in military aid to the Saudi campaign last Friday

This week will see the arrival of around 1,500 US Marines in Darwin in the fourth rotation coming out of a deal to increase US Marine presence in Australia. Brendan O’Connor of the University of Sydney warns that this isn’t a ‘deal with Obama’ and that Australian acceptance of an increased presence may change with a change in US Presidency.

Continuing from previous discussions on gender equality in the US military, Juliet Eilperin from The Washington Post, discusses the need for institutional change regarding transgender people in the military. Back at home, the ADF recently launched a campaign aimed at recruiting more females into the services.

Finally over at VICE News, read the first in a three-part series that follows Kaj Larsen—a former US Navy Seal—as he embeds with the Nigerian military as they battle Boko Haram.

Air, land and counterterrorism updates

An F/A-18C Hornet aircraft assigned to Marine Fighter Attack Training Squadron (VMFAT) 101 flies over the flight deck of the aircraft carrier USS George H.W. Bush (CVN 77) in the Atlantic Ocean.

Flight Path

Two US Marine Corps F/A-18C Hornets made an emergency landing at Tainan Air Force Base, Taiwan, on 1 April after the pilots reported a mechanical issue. The landing was dismissed as precautionary, but Michael Cole from The Diplomat suggests that it could be a strategic signal in response to Chinese assertiveness.

To maintain the US’ technological advantage, American aviation is accelerating the development of ‘degraded visual environment technology’ to allow helicopters to fly in rain, snow, fog or dust. Also on the list of future capability are hacker-proof helicopters and drones that can both fly and swim. Hacker-proof helicopters are designed to ensure that adversaries are unable to take command over weaponised or surveillance UAVs—technology that will no doubt be desirable on other military aircraft.

Falklands redux? Argentinian plans to procure at least 12 Chinese fighter jets have led the UK to explore options to update its air defence system in the Falkland Islands. Tension is set to escalate with recent allegations that the British government spied on the Argentine government between 2006–11, and British discoveries of oil and gas reserves north of the islands.

Turning now to current operations, Saudi-led coalition airstrikes continue in Yemen, while Kenyan fighter jets have launched airstrikes against al-Shabaab targets in northern Somalia. US airstrikes in Iraq have helped to reclaim the IS-held city of Tikrit. This ABC video offers an insight into the airstrike operations from a US aircraft carrier on the Persian Gulf.

Rapid Fire

Debate rages on between Alan Dupont and Hugh White on Australian defence strategy and irregular warfare. To get up to speed, start with Professor Dupont’s paper here, then a follow up response by Professor White, then a rebuttal, a reply, and the latest instalment.

General Wesley Clark, former NATO Supreme Allied Commander, delivered a briefing last week at the Atlantic Council on military assistance to Ukraine. The briefing analyses the hybrid form of warfare being conducted by aggressors and forecasts an attack against Ukrainian forces within the next 60 days. A video of the briefing can also be viewed in full here.

VICE news reports that Russian soldiers have ‘given up pretending’ that they’re not involved in the conflict in Ukraine. The report is based on a BBC interview (available here, in Russian) with Russian volunteer soldier Dmitry Sapozhnikov, a self-declared Special Forces squad leader for the Donetsk People’s Republic. The interview gives previously undisclosed details of the battle for Debaltseve, including the involvement of Russian generals in leading the operation.

CT Scan

The return of Matthew Gardiner, an Australian believed to have assisted Kurdish forces overseas, puts Australia’s foreign fighter laws to the test. The case also reveals the awkward reality that evidentiary issues—particularly the extraction of evidence from overseas conflict zones—will make prosecuting foreign fighters hard.

In a bid to make sense of the Garissa attack in Kenya, Jeffrey Gettleman of The New York Times explains that a weakened al Shabaab has led it to its new strategy of ‘mass murder on the cheap’. Explanations for al Shabaab’s grim success range from arguments that the international community lacks engagement with it as a global issue, to Kenya’s colonial ‘roots’.

France is rolling out the ‘Islam à la Française’, a national campaign teaching the French interpretation of secularism to Muslim figures and public officials. However, Muslim leaders retorted that in mosques, ‘everyone speaks out against extremism’ already. In the UK, police hired a British Muslim comedian to hold CT workshops for teens, revolving around a skit in which the comedian’s cousin becomes radicalised (15 mins).

Finally, this Washington Post article looks at the ‘hidden hand’ behind the Islamic State: Saddam Hussein.

Herding cats: the US rebalance

U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry arrives in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, on October 10, 2013.Ask any specialist on Asian security to describe the strategic policies of China’s neighbours and you’re more likely than not to hear the word ‘hedging’ in the reply. As they become increasingly integrated with the Chinese economy, most of the countries of Eastern Asia have developed progressively strong defence linkages with the United States, and apparently each other.

Indeed, much of the logic of Washington’s ‘pivot’ or ‘rebalancing’ strategy (depending on whom you’re talking to) seems to be predicated on Asian hedging. The United States, so the logic of the pivot goes, can use enhanced defence relationships in the western Pacific to bolster the predominance of its alliance system at a time of constrained defence spending, precisely because of the wariness of Pacific Asia about China’s growing clout.

It’s a logic that international relations theory would endorse. Alliance theorists from Waltz to Walt tell us that a growing threat will be met with ever greater solidarity among those it threatens. Read more

Reader response: Australia is more and less than a middle power

Punching above our weight - kangaroo boxingAnthony Bergin is surely right when he channels his inner Alexander Downer to make the case that Australia is more (but also, I think, sometimes less) than a middle power in international affairs. Any real estate agent can tell you why: location, location, location. As the regional hegemon across a huge but underpopulated oceanic expanse at the fringes of Pacific, Indian and Southern Oceans, Australia is the superpower of a region that most of the world never thinks about.

 But in some ways we are less than a middle power too. The well-worn foreign affairs boilerplates of Australia being a “clear-eyed” power that “punches above its weight” are of diminishing utility. Yes we are a generous aid spender and a good international citizen, but we sometimes use those qualities to avoid rather than embrace the challenges of leadership. On the tough issues that matter—such as making contributions commensurate with our interests to global public goods like freedom of the high seas or addressing climate change—we often prefer to free-ride rather than lead. Read more

Coming soon: AUSMIN on the big screen

A 1908 postcard welcoming the Americans to Australia.At some point towards the end of the year, Prime Minister Tony Abbott will face one of the biggest diplomatic tests of his new administration: his government’s first Australia—United States Ministerial (AUSMIN) meeting. These annual gatherings of foreign and defence ministers have been the political high point of the alliance relationship since the mid-1980s when New Zealand exiled itself from trilateral ANZUS Council meetings. A very small number of AUSMINs were cancelled or delayed in the early 1990s, but none since then and new Australian ministers will presumably be eager to strengthen their alliance credentials.

This year’s AUSMIN should be in the United States, following the odd theatre of the 2012 ‘nothing to see here’ meeting in Perth. Readers will recall this was the meeting when Australian ministers Bob Carr and Stephen Smith went to great lengths beforehand to deny that the US was worried about Australian defence spending cuts and wouldn’t raise this in talks. (The US was worried, and did raise the cuts.) This was also the meeting when an enthusiastic Hillary Clinton and Leon Panetta were effusive at the post-Ministerial media conference about big steps taken in defence and space cooperation, only to find Carr and Smith—perhaps unused to delivering such policy substance—deadpanning a ‘nothing much is going on here’ routine. Read more

Not a lot atoll

PrintYou can do a lot with a coral atoll. The US uses the leased UK territory of Diego Garcia ‘To provide forward support to operational forces forward deployed to the Indian Ocean and Persian Gulf…’. That includes logistical support for naval and air forces, and makes Washington’s job of projecting power into the Indian Ocean and Persian Gulf regions far simpler than it otherwise would be.


View Larger Map

The new Defence White Paper confirms the implementation of the ADF Posture Review recommendations to make military use of the Cocos (Keeling) Islands, which lie about 1100 km from Indonesia, and 2100 km from Australia’s North West Cape.

The government will be…

…expanding the capacity of infrastructure to meet Navy’s future basing requirements; and upgrading airbases to better support aircraft operations, including for P-8A maritime surveillance operations from Cocos (Keeling) Islands.

Of course the Cocos are smaller than Diego Garcia. There isn’t the space to provide the same level of logistic support, so we probably won’t see major and permanent bases there. Nevertheless, the position of the atoll will make it a useful operational asset as the Indian Ocean and South East Asian sea lanes take on greater significance.

Andrew Davies is a senior analyst for defence capability at ASPI and executive editor of The StrategistHarry White is an analyst at ASPI.

Australia–UK defence arrangements

Minister Carr and UK Foreign Minister William Hague, AUKMIN talks, Perth January 18 2013 Photo: Ron D'Raine

Editor’s note: we at ASPI value contestability and independence of thought so we’re sometimes surprised when people think that there’s a single ‘official’ ASPI position on a topic. That isn’t the case—we practice contestability inside ASPI as well and have no ‘house line’. Today’s posts are an example of that: Ben Schreer and I take a ‘glass half empty’ look at the recent announcement of enhanced Australia–UK defence arrangements, while Peter Jennings sees the positives of the new developments. AD

Strategy or industry?

By: Andrew Davies & Benjamin Schreer

There’s been a lot said in the last week or so about the enduring interests of the United Kingdom in our part of the world. The reason for that, of course, is the fifth Australia UK Ministerial Consultations (AUKMIN) held in Perth last week. Lots was made of the common strategic and economic interests, values and history of the two participants. And both parties are members of the Five Power Defence Arrangement—a regional security institution that looks at first glance like a legacy of another age, but still has a significant role in life.

Like all good high-level meetings, it produced a formal communiqué that reflected all of the positives of the joint relationship. And perhaps surprisingly to those who don’t follow these matters closely, it announced the signing of the Australia–United Kingdom Defence and Security Cooperation Treaty. The signing of a new treaty often flags part of a grand strategy. The signing of ANZUS, for example heralded a very significant turn in Australia’s thinking on its security—away, as it happens, from the United Kingdom after it was unable to provide for the security of its antipodean former colony in 1942 and towards the United States. It was a big deal. Read more